The Israeli Film Directors Pushing for a Reckoning in Their Home Country
🤖 AI Summary
Overview
This episode explores the controversial Israeli documentary Naza, which investigates the Israeli military's methods in Gaza following the Hamas-led attacks of October 7, 2023. The film has sparked global acclaim and intense backlash in Israel, including threats against its directors, Yuval Abraham and Rachel Shor. The discussion delves into the film's revelations, the societal and political reactions, and the directors' motivations and personal risks.
Notable Quotes
- Netanyahu just a few days ago said that our film is like ballistic missiles being targeted at Israel.
— Yuval Abraham, on the political backlash to Naza.
- We designed a system predicated on mass surveillance that routinely and systematically on a massive scale marks private houses as targets.
— Yuval Abraham, on the Israeli military's targeting methods.
- We want to change the place. We want policies that we disagree with to change, and we want the place to be better for Israelis and for Palestinians.
— Yuval Abraham, on the directors' motivations for creating the film.
🎥 The Film’s Premise and Controversy
- Naza features testimony from 24 anonymous Israeli intelligence officers and soldiers, revealing the military's targeting methods in Gaza, including the use of AI and mass surveillance.
- The film's title, Naza, is derived from a Hebrew euphemism for collateral damage,
highlighting the dehumanization of civilian casualties.
- Despite its acclaim abroad, including a record-breaking standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival, the film has provoked outrage in Israel, with accusations of betrayal and threats to revoke the directors' citizenship.
- Protesters have targeted Rachel Shor’s family home, calling for violence against the filmmakers.
🏠 Targeting Civilians in Gaza
- The film reveals that Israeli intelligence often targeted Hamas members in their private homes, not necessarily because of military activity but because it was easier to locate them there.
- This strategy led to the deaths of entire families, complicating the narrative that Hamas uses civilians as human shields.
- Surveillance systems like Where is Daddy
tracked family members of targets, and AI algorithms flagged tens of thousands of potential targets based on phone behavior patterns, often with minimal human oversight.
- One officer claimed a strike was approved with the knowledge that up to 500 civilians could be killed, a figure disputed by the Israeli military.
🧠 Psychological Distance and Dehumanization
- The film explores the psychological distance between Israeli soldiers and the civilians they target, facilitated by remote operations and euphemistic language like collateral damage.
- Soldiers grappled with their roles, with some expressing guilt and comparing their actions to historical atrocities.
- One officer admitted to realizing he had participated in what he described as genocide, highlighting the moral reckoning faced by those involved.
📺 Visual Storytelling and Societal Disconnect
- The film juxtaposes interviews with soldiers against scenes of daily life in Tel Aviv, emphasizing the stark disconnect between the city’s normalcy and the violence in Gaza just 40 miles away.
- A recurring motif is Israelis watching sanitized news coverage, which uses terms like terror targets
to obscure the human cost of military actions.
- The film concludes with rare footage from Gaza, ensuring viewers confront the human toll of the events described.
⚖️ Ethics, Journalism, and Backlash
- The directors defend their decision to include controversial claims, such as the 500-casualty strike, asserting that they were rigorously corroborated.
- They reject the notion that exposing these truths could fuel anti-Semitism, emphasizing the importance of journalistic integrity and accountability.
- Despite death threats and political pressure, the directors remain committed to their vision of fostering an honest reckoning in Israel to create a better future for both Israelis and Palestinians.
AI-generated content may not be accurate or complete and should not be relied upon as a sole source of truth.
📋 Episode Description
The documentary film “NAZA,” which investigates the methods the Israeli military has used in the war in Gaza since the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, received a record-breaking standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival last month. Just a few days later, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he would propose legislation that could revoke the directors’ Israeli citizenship, arguing that they had defamed their country.
Now, with a global theatrical release underway, the directors spoke with “The Daily” to discuss the film and all the pushback that it — and they — have experienced.
Guest:
- Rachel Szor, an Israeli investigative journalist, film director and activist.
- Yuval Abraham, an Israeli investigative journalist, film director and Arabic-Hebrew translator.
Background reading:
- After accolades abroad, “NAZA” met backlash at home.
- Read The Times’s review of the film.
Photo: Stefano Rellandini/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images, The Guardian/IFC Center, Ander Gillenea/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.