🤖 AI Summary
Overview
This episode delves into the creation of The New York Times Magazine's list of the 30 greatest living American songwriters. It explores the rigorous selection process, the diverse traditions of songwriting, and features interviews with some of the honorees, including Taylor Swift, Jay-Z, and Nile Rodgers. The discussion also highlights the challenges of ranking creative talent and the cultural significance of songwriting in America.
Notable Quotes
- Criticism has been a huge fuel for me. It’s been a jumping-off point, like a creative writing prompt.
– Taylor Swift, on using criticism as inspiration for her songwriting.
- For me, I thrive when I’m challenged to make a word mean more—triple entendre, quadruple entendre. That’s when I feel like I’m at my best.
– Jay-Z, on the art of crafting intricate rhymes.
- These songs sound like they’ve always been there, like they were found under a rock.
– Jody Rosen, on Nile Rodgers’ timeless disco anthems.
🎵 The Process of Creating the List
- Sasha Weiss, deputy editor of The Times Magazine, described the process as a mix of crowd-sourced ballots and intense debates among critics. Over 700 names were initially considered.
- The final list aimed to reflect the diversity of American music, from Nashville’s country roots to hip-hop and avant-garde indie.
- Iconic figures like Stevie Wonder and Bob Dylan were obvious inclusions, while others, like Billy Joel, sparked heated debates. Joel’s exclusion was attributed to the need for hard choices and representation of broader traditions.
🎤 Taylor Swift’s Songwriting Genius
- Joe Coscarelli explored Taylor Swift’s songwriting evolution, from her early country hits to her pop dominance. Swift’s use of plot twists, idioms, and rant bridges
were highlighted as hallmarks of her craft.
- Swift revealed her meticulous attention to detail, such as avoiding consecutive words with the same ending and starting letters.
- She discussed how criticism inspired hits like Blank Space
and Anti-Hero,
and emphasized the importance of responding to criticism through art rather than directly engaging with detractors.
🎶 Jay-Z and the Art of Hip-Hop Storytelling
- Jody Rosen interviewed Jay-Z, emphasizing his mastery of storytelling and technical prowess in rap.
- Jay-Z shared his process of starting with a flow and building lyrics around it, often crafting intricate rhymes with multiple layers of meaning.
- Songs like Dead Presidents II
exemplify his ability to blend personal narrative with wordplay and cultural commentary.
🎸 The Nashville Songwriting Tradition
- Songwriters Brandy Clark, Shane McAnally, and Josh Osborne were celebrated for their contributions to country music.
- They operate within Nashville’s Music Row
tradition, treating songwriting as a collaborative, 9-to-5 job.
- Their hits, like Kacey Musgraves’ Follow Your Arrow
and Merry Go ‘Round,
challenge traditional country themes with progressive storytelling.
💃 Nile Rodgers and the Timelessness of Disco
- Jody Rosen highlighted Nile Rodgers’ influence on disco and pop music, with hits like Good Times,
I’m Coming Out,
and Le Freak.
- Rodgers shared the inspiration behind I’m Coming Out,
which struck him during a night out at a club. He recognized its potential as both an anthem for the LGBTQ+ community and a commercial success.
- His music is described as both innovative and timeless, embodying a universal appeal that transcends generations.
AI-generated content may not be accurate or complete and should not be relied upon as a sole source of truth.
📋 Episode Description
Roughly a year ago, a team at The New York Times Magazine set about tackling a nearly impossible task: creating a list of the greatest living American songwriters. But how to take the tens of thousands of songwriters working in this country and narrow them down to a digestible list? The answer involved thousands of voting ballots, hundreds of music industry insiders and a series of closed-door meetings among a small group of music experts. The result, The Times’s list of the 30 greatest living American songwriters, was published this week.
Today, Michael Barbaro talks with Sasha Weiss, a deputy editor of The Times Magazine, who oversaw the project, as well as Joe Coscarelli and Jody Rosen, two members of the cadre of critics assigned with compiling the final list. They discuss the list-making process, what defines a great songwriter and why Billy Joel didn’t make the final cut.
We also hear from some of the songwriters featured on the list, including Taylor Swift, Nile Rodgers and the songwriting team of Brandy Clark, Shane McAnally and Josh Osborne.
On Today's Episode:
Sasha Weiss is a deputy editor of The New York Times Magazine.
Joe Coscarelli is a culture reporter for The Times. He is a co-host of “Popcast,” a producer of the “Song of the Week” video series and the author of “Rap Capital: An Atlanta Story.”
Jody Rosen is a contributing writer for the magazine and the author of “Two Wheels Good: The History and Mystery of the Bicycle.”
Background Reading:
The 30 Greatest Living American Songwriters
Cast Your Vote for the Greatest Living American Songwriters
Photo credit: Stefan Ruiz for The New York Times
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal